Broken Records (Edinburgh band) Gig Review
ALBUM REVIEWS :: NEWS :: CRUD RADIO ::NEW RELEASES::PREVIEWS::HOME
 
SAVE DARFUR
 
 
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
MEDIA STREAM PREVIEW
play with Windows Media
Play Crud Radio - 1 hour of great music mixed exclusively for Crud
CRUD MUSIC MAG  ALERTS

MUSIC POLLS
Most Convincing Northerner
John Simm
Liam Gallagher
Peter Kay
Max Beesley
Vernon Kay

View Weekly Poll Results


Wild Beasts ~ Smother
Arctic Monkeys ~ Suck It And See!
Cass McCombs ~ Wits End
Daedelus ~ Bespoke
Crystal Stilts ~ In Love With Oblivion
Poly Styrene ~ Generation Indigo
De Staat ~ Machinery
Undertones ~ True Confessions
King Creosote and Jon Hopkins ~ Diamond Mine
Gorillaz ~ The Fall
Anna Calvi ~ Anna Calvi

latest news

Young Knives ~ May UK Tour
Swimming With Dolphins ~ 'Water Colours'
Katy Perry ~ California Dreams 2011 World Tour
Anna Calvi ~ Arctic Monkeys ~ Mumford and Sons Gigs
Antony and the Johnsons ~ Swanlights EP
Junior Boys ~ 'Banana Ripple' single
Alex Turner ~ Submarine EP
Asobi Seksu ~ April Tour Dates
King Creosote / John Hopkins ~ Union Chapel Gig
White Stripes ~ White Stripes Split
Echo and the Bunnymen ~ North American Tour Dates

features

Pipettes - Earth Versus the Pipettes
New Wave to New Beat
LCD Sound System - This Is Happening
Eels/BBC4 Parallel Worlds
Arctic Monkeys Live @ Wembley Arena
Twilight Sad @ ICA London
Flaming Lips Live @ The Troxy
Nick Cave @ Hammersmith Apollo
The National Live @ The Royal Festival Hall
Guillemots Shepherd’s Bush Empire London

interviews

:: Frightened Rabbit
:: Teitur
:: Tom Williams and the Boat
:: Scritti Politti
:: Charlotte Hatherley
:: Delays
:: Editors
:: Grandaddy
:: Willy Mason
:: Palace Fires
:: Santa Sprees

    

Broken Records @ 229, London, 05.09.08

Broken Records - Club Fandango

Scaramouche, scaramouche will you do the Club Fandango? Only if we have to. James Berry may fail to find a bolt of lightning in the five young men who've been chasing their own spark for years, but not so Edinburgh's Broken Records.

23/09/2008

Club Fandango is slam-kerrang in the middle of its second annual 5-day Fistful Of Fandango knees-up tonight, in celebration of all things that are (a) very indie or (b) really indie but not so much that a T4 presenter would know who they were or (c) just generally a bit of indie below the radar. It’s kind of like the NME Awards but without the grazing herds of Fratellis fans or sinister brainwashing undertones. The sense of occasion might suffer – it’s a Friday night but at times feels like a Student’s Union mid-weeker, with the drinks promotions off – but staggering the acts over 2 rooms so that you don’t have to miss a minute of any band on the bill is very much in the spirit of discovery and a hierarchy is fairly non-existent, so in that sense it excels.

London 5-piece Prego represent what these nights are all about, though possibly in the wrong way. Chiming indie in the Death Cab For Cutie vein played valiantly by unremarkable men who’ve been at it for years chasing a spark they think they may once have seen. The Ruling Class aren’t even chasing their own spark, choosing instead The Charlatans’; it’s amusingly uncanny for a song or two, right down to the bowl haircut and pout. Red Light Company are hyper professional and surely bound to succeed in a world where Editors and The Killers sell oodles and they do feel less focus-group than on record, though the singer still has a little too much metal-fan-at-science-camp about him. Air Traffic then close the evening as the Scouting For Girls that, er, never got the girls.

But it’s second room headliners Broken Records we’re here to catch tonight before the hype catches up and smothers them. “The Scottish Arcade Fire!” is the approved hyperbolic soundbyte that’s been gaining weight size since their self-titled EP hit the ground whirling at the beginning of this year. This probably says more about people’s desire to see the great Arcade Fire of Edinburgh though, as it hardly holds much water.

Sure, there are seven of the blighters up there, often going hell for leather and creased trousers, romping with the assistance of a fine festoon of instrumentation (trumpet, fiddle, accordion, cello, ukulele), unbridled and somewhat carefree if you don’t count a verbal hankering to get people dancing. It really is a bracing, fluid performance - even if it lacks the discernable point of breakthrough that it will at some point need. It’s also very much more rooted in folk traditionalism, rather than the emotionally draining, apocalyptic new wave reworkings of Canada’s most notable. But the north of the border Bright Eyes (much nearer the truth, say we) seem to be setting down roots capable of holding firm for years.

Broken Records - click to enlarge Broken Records - click to enlarge Broken Records - click to enlarge Broken Records - click to enlarge
Broken Records - click to enlarge Broken Records - click to enlarge Broken Records - click to enlarge

Relevant sites:
www.myspace.com/brokenrecordsedinburgh



James Berry for Crud Magazine 2008©


08/08 XXTeens - Coordinates Interview
08/08 Rogue Wave - Coordinates Interview
09/08 Frightened Rabbit - Coordinates Interview
09/08 Broken Records - Live Review - Club Fandango
10/08 Ten Kens - Coordinates Interview
11/08 Tenebrous Liar - Coordinates Interview
12/08 Brakes - Xmas Coordinates Interview
12/08 Ten kens - Xmas Coordinates Interview
12/08 The Leisure Society - Xmas Coordinates Interview
12/08 Hazel Winter - Xmas Coordinates
02/09 Starsailor (Wigan) - Live Review - Luminaire

January 2001
July - August 2001
September - October 2001
November - December 2001
January - March 2002
April - July 2002
August - December 2002
January - March 2003
May - August 2003
November 2003
January - March 2004
April - September 2004

October - December 2004
January - March 2005
April - December 2005
January - August 2006
September - December 2006
January - September 2007
October - December 2007
January - May 2008
June-December 2008


 
 
 

 

© CRUD MUSIC MAGAZINE/
2-4-7-MUSIC.COM 2009

STILL refusing to dumb it down.

CRUD MUSIC MAGAZINE HOME :: NEW RELEASES :: MUSIC REVIEWS :: MYCRUDSPACE :: MEDIA STREAMS :: MUSIC NEWS :: ADVERTISING :: POLLS :: CONTACT US ::
***AVERTISEMENT***
Room4U.org.uk - Up to 75% OFF standard rates
***AVERTISEMENT***
Crud Magazine is set up and maintained in accordance with permissions and conditions agreed by all parties.